
Expand Menu

BEVERAGES
CHOCOLATE MILK

$1.99
COFFEE
Click To Order
Click For Price
COKE

$2.25
DIET COKE

$2.25
FANTA ORANGE

$2.25
HOT CHOCOLATE

$1.85
ICE CREAM FLOAT

$4.00
ICED COFFEE

Specify vanilla or caramel or pumpkin with milk or not
$2.50
ITALIAN SODA

$1.75
LEMONADE

$2.25
MILK

$1.99
ROOT BEER

$2.25
SPRITE

$2.25
STRAWBERRY PATCH LEMONADE

$2.99
SWEET TEA

$2.25
UNSWEETENED TEA

$2.25

APPETIZERS
BABY POTATO CAKES

Five seasoned potato cakes served with BBQ Sauce
$2.99
CHEESE QUESADILLA

Crispy tortilla filled with melted cheese served with tortilla chips and sour cream and salsa on the side
$7.25
CHICKEN QUESADILLA

Crispy tortilla filled with melted cheese and grilled chicken served with tortilla chips and sour cream and salsa on the side
$10.74
CHIPS AND DIP

Bowl of kettle cooked chips served with BBQ, ranch and chicken salad
$4.50
LOADED POTATO CAKES

Eight seasoned potato cakes topped with melted cheddar, bacon and served with sour cream
$5.99
NACHOS

Tortilla chips topped with melted cheddar, sour cream and salsa on the side
$5.25
PA DUTCH PLATTER

A platter of leaf lettuce with chicken salad, cheese slices, red beet egg, sweet bologna and crackers
$7.75

GRILLED SANDWICHES
200 BLOCK

American, cheddar, and provolone cheese all grilled on wheat bread
$5.25
ADULT HOT DOG
Click To Order
$4.95
BALER BEEF

Grilled sliced roast beef, cheddar cheese and BBQ sauce on a kaiser roll
$8.25
CLARION (RACHEL)

(also known as a Rachel) Roast beef or roasted turkey, swiss cheese, coleslaw, 1,000 island, grilled on deli rye
$9.99
CLASSIC GRILLED CHEESE
American cheese between slices of country white bread grilled to perfection
Click To Order
$4.99
CUBAN

Grilled ham, hard salami, swiss cheese, dill pickles, spicy brown mustard, grilled on crunchy ciabatta
$8.99
GARDEN SPOT MELT

Creamy chicken salad (Iron's deli recipe!) with bacon and cheddar cheese served on grilled ciabatta
$9.49
NH GRILLER

Thick cut slice of sweet bologna, provolone, cheddar, and yellow mustard grilled on wheat bread
$7.99
PRETZEL MELT

Locally made in an Amish bakery, choose from Ham and Cheese, Cheese Steak, or Pork BBQ encased in baked pretzel dough
$7.99
SALES BARN

Sliced roast beef and melted provolone cheese, on a toasted sub roll served with a side of beef au jus
$8.99
TOWN CLOCK (REUBEN)

also known as a Reuben) Roast beef or roasted turkey, swiss cheese, sauerkraut, 1,000 island, grilled on deli rye
$9.75
TRIMMER'S

Roasted turkey, crispy bacon, cheddar cheese, lettuce, mayonnaise, apple butter and apple slices on grilled ciabatta
$10.49
VEGGIE MELT

Provolone and cheddar cheese with tomato, lettuce, and cucumber on grilled deli rye with your choice of dressing
$6.25
WEAVER'S

Grilled chicken breast, melted cheddar cheese, bacon lettuce, tomato, and ranch or BBQ dressing on a kaiser roll
$9.75

WRAPS
BLACK BEAN WRAP

Black beans, pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, Tex-Mex rice and salsa
$7.49
BRIMMER

Fresh roasted turkey, crispy bacon, Ranch, american cheese, lettuce and tomato
$9.49
CHICKEN CAESAR WRAP

Grilled chicken breast, romaine lettuce, croutons, and fresh parmesan cheese covered with a creamy tusacn caesar dressing
$9.75
MAIN STREET

Grilled ham, swiss cheese, sliced apples, and spicy brown mustard
$7.99
OLD BAY CHICKEN

Grilled chicken breast, pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato and Old Bay mayonnaise
$9.25
RUBINSON'S

Creamy chicken salad with dried cranberries, almonds, lettuce, and tomato
$9.75
SMOKEY BBQ

Grilled chicken breast topped with tangy BBQ sauce, cheddar cheese, and coleslaw
$9.25
SPARTAN BLEU

Grilled chicken breast and chipped ham with swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, and honey mustard
$10.25
VEGGIE WRAP
Cucumbers, onions, lettuce, tomato, and provolone with your choice of dressing
Click To Order
$6.75
WILD BUFFALO

Grilled chicken, provolone cheese, hot sauce, lettuce and tomato with your choice of bleu cheese or ranch
$9.49

SIGNATURE SUNDAES
CLASSIC BROWNIE SUNDAE

Click For Price
CMP

Click For Price
COOKIE BOTTOM

$5.00
FLIGHT ICE CREAM
Click To Order
$6.25
GARDEN PATCH
Click To Order
Click For Price
HOT FUDGE BANANA BOAT

$5.50
HOT WAFFLE SUNDAE

$5.00
HOT WAFFLES SANDWICH

Click For Price
JAILHOUSE ROCK

Click For Price
JIMINY CRICKET

Click For Price
LICKITY SPLIT BANANA SPLIT

$6.00
MUSTY DUSTY ROAD

Click For Price
NUTS ABOUT NEW HOLLAND

Click For Price
PLOWED FIELD

Click For Price
SALTED CARAMEL BROWNIE

Click For Price
SWEET ROAD APPLE

Click For Price
WET AND MUDDY ROAD

Click For Price

SALADS
CAESAR SALAD

Romaine lettuce, croutons, fresh parmesan and Caesar dressing
Click For Price
CHEF SALAD

Mixed greens, turkey, ham, swiss, red beet egg, tomatoes and croutons
$10.25
LICKITY SPLIT SALAD

Mixed greens, tomatocucumbers, shredded cheese and potato sticks
Click For Price
ORCHARD SALAD

Mixed greens, mandarin oranges, apples, dried cranberries, almonds, and cucumbers served with poppyseed dressing
Click For Price
SPRING HOUSE SALAD

Mixed greens with dried cranberries, almonds, tomatoes and onions (Does not contain sprouts as seen in the picture)
Click For Price

SIGNATURE SANDWICHES
BLT

Crisp bacon, lettuce, and tomato with mayonnaise on your choice of toast
$6.49
CLUB

A triple-decker with ham, roasted turkey, american cheese, lettuce, tomato, bacon and mayonnaise on your choice of toast
$9.49
RAILROAD

Provolone cheese, capicola ham, hard salami, lettuce, tomato, parmesan cheese, oregano and olive oil on a sub roll
$8.49
THANKSGIVING DAY

Roasted turkey, warm stuffing, cranberry sauce and mayonnaise on a kaiser roll
$8.99

CLASSIC BURGERS
Monday's only
BACON CHEESEBURGER

Monday's only
$9.50
BACON RANCH BURGER
Monday's only
Click To Order
$9.75
BBQ BURGER
Monday's only
Click To Order
$9.75
CAESAR BURGER
Monday's only
Click To Order
$8.75
CHEESEBURGER

Monday's only
$8.50
CHILI BURGER
Click To Order
$9.99
HAMBURGER

Monday's only
$7.99
ITALIAN BURGER
Monday's only
Click To Order
$8.75
MAC BURGER
Click To Order
$9.99
MEXICAN BURGER
Monday's only
Click To Order
$9.25
OLD BAY BURGER
Monday's only
Click To Order
$8.75
PATTY MELT
Monday's only
Click To Order
$8.25
SPECIAL BURGER
Monday's only check Facebook for description
Click To Order
$8.75
LICKITY SPLIT
We are a unique family owned and operated cafe. We make everything fresh and in house daily. Our soups are homemade and even our turkey is roasted just perfectly for our sandwiches. Stop in for our famous signature sundaes, shakes, floats, and gelati or try our delectable sandwiches, wraps, appetizers, soups, and salads. Lickity Split has everything your taste buds desire! Order online today for quick and easy carry-out! We are located at 209 East Main Street in the heart of New Holland just a few blocks west of Community Memorial Park, and 5 minutes East of New Holland Shopping Center.100%
of 118 customers recommendedHours of Business
Sunday
Closed
Monday - Saturday
11:00 AM - 8:00 PM
Mo,Tu,We,Th,Fr,Sa 11:00-20:00
Share on:
Share on Facebook
Share on Google
Share on LinkedIn
Share on Pintrest
Share on Twitter
Sandwiches,American,Dessert,Salads,Hamburgers,Wraps,Soup